9 Best Pizza Spots in Colorado Springs That Locals Actually Love

Colorado Springs has no shortage of pizza joints, but finding one worth skipping your usual spot for is trickier than it looks. We've eaten through the options — from foldable New York slices on Tejon Street to craft pies coming out of brewpubs near Garden of the Gods — and these are the places that earned a second visit. Some are quick, some are an occasion. All of them are worth it.

The Real-Deal Slice Shops

1. Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colorado Springs

Credit: Fat Sully's NY Pizza

The crust at Fat Sully's has that New York snap — thin enough to fold lengthwise without apology, with just enough char on the bottom to remind you this isn't a frozen situation. It's downtown on South Tejon, which means parking can be a mood on weekends, but the price point makes it easy to forgive. Regulars who grew up eating real New York pizza consistently say this one holds up. Get there early on a Friday before the bar crowd arrives.

---

2. Leon Gessi New York Pizza

Credit: Leon Gessi New York Pizza

Leon Gessi on Palmer Park Boulevard passes the fold test. That's the shorthand around here for real New York-style pizza, and the crust at Gessi — thin, crispy, slightly chewy at the edge — holds up to anyone who grew up with the real thing. The Kitchen Sink pizza is the move if you're going big. The meatball sub is the move if you're going practical. The marinara is tangy and confident. It's a dive in the best sense: no pretense, plastic booths, and pizza that has nothing to prove.

"Pies With a Pint

3. Voodoo Brewing -Colorado Springs

Credit: Voodoo Brewing

Voodoo Brewing sits off Garden of the Gods Road with the kind of interior that makes you want to stay longer than you planned. The decor runs weird and fun, the beer list is real, and the pizza is the kind of thing you order because your dining companion dared you to try a brewpub pie — and then you end up fighting over the last slice. The Powder Run vanilla beer is a genuine find. Grab a barstool and budget more time than you think you'll need.

---

4. Colorado Mountain Brewery

Credit: Colorado Mountain Brewery

Colorado Mountain Brewery at Interquest is where you end up after a day on the trails when you need something substantial and a pint that was brewed within the same zip code. The bison burger gets most of the attention — deservedly — but the overall experience here is about the room as much as the menu. It fills up, the bar staff keeps pace, and the cider pork chops are the sleeper pick that regulars quietly order while everyone else goes obvious. Worth the drive up to the north end of town.

"Worth the Stop While You're There

5. Denver Biscuit Co. - Colorado Springs

Credit: Denver Biscuit Co.

Denver Biscuit Co. made its name on the other side of the Rockies, but the Colorado Springs location on South Tejon has developed a following all its own. The biscuits arrive golden and pull-apart soft, and the strawberry jam situation is worth mentioning to people who care about that sort of thing. This is a weekend brunch destination — expect a wait, expect it to be worth it. The cold brew is strong enough to make you feel like a person again before noon.

---

6. Black Bear Diner Colorado Springs - Academy

Credit: Black Bear Diner Colorado Springs

Black Bear Diner on Academy runs on two things: generous portions and that particular comfort-food energy that makes you want to unbutton your jeans by the end of the meal. The chicken dinner draws repeat visitors, and the server attentiveness gets mentioned enough in reviews that it's clearly a priority here, not an accident. It gets festive during the holidays — the diner leans into seasonal decor in a way that feels genuine rather than corporate. Portions easily feed two if you order smart.

---

7. The Exercise Coach of North Colorado Springs

Credit: The Exercise Coach of North Colorado Springs

The Exercise Coach tucked into Briar Village Point is the kind of place that earns its five-star average through consistency rather than novelty. The 20-minute workout model is genuinely efficient — the trainers here, including Ella, Shelby, and Ian, are noted specifically by name in review after review, which tells you something about the personal investment on the staff side. If your goal is to arrive at Machu Picchu without embarrassing yourself, apparently this is your starting point. Small studio, personalized sessions, no crowded weight room politics.

8. MOD Pizza

Credit: MOD Pizza

MOD Pizza on North Academy is the fast-casual option that actually earns its keep. Unlimited toppings on a cauliflower crust sounds like a compromise; it isn't. The gluten-free build is genuinely good — not "good for gluten-free," just good — and the chicken sausage is a better call than it sounds. Skip mobile ordering on Friday evenings unless you enjoy anxiety. Walk in, watch them build it in front of you, and it comes out of the oven fast enough that you'll be back in your car before the indecision hits.

New spots keep opening along Tejon and up toward the Powers corridor, so we'll refresh this list as things shake out. Seasonal menus at the brewpubs are worth checking before you go — both Voodoo and Colorado Mountain rotate things around more than their regular menus let on. Which of these have you actually eaten at, and what did we miss?